Skip to content
Call (323) 522-3410 · Free delivery available nationwide, and a 120-night comfort exchange on mattresses
Call (323) 522-3410 · Free delivery
Stearns & Foster pillow top mattress seen from the front, with the separate cushioned top layer sewn above the mattress body

Pillow top, Euro top or tight top: which mattress top is right for you?

Look at a row of mattresses from the side and you will see three shapes: a flat, quilted surface that runs straight into the sides; a thick extra cushion sewn on top, with a seam where it meets the mattress; and that cushion squared off flush with the edges. Those are a tight top, a pillow top and a Euro top. Here is how each is built, how it feels, who it suits and how it wears.

One thing first: the top is not the firmness. Our firmness guide puts it this way: support "comes from the coils or the dense foam at the bottom of the mattress," while firmness "is what you feel in the first few seconds, and it comes from the top layers." A top changes how much cushioning sits over the support, which is why we carry pillow tops labeled firm. If you are still choosing between coils, foam and latex, start with our hybrid vs memory foam vs innerspring guide.

Tight top: the cover sewn flat

On a tight top the cover and a thin quilt are sewn straight over the comfort layers, with no separate layer on top. The surface is flat and taut, and the sides run straight up to it. Aireloom's Tight Top, for example, has its comfort foams "sewn flat under the cover, over the wrapped coils," as our Aireloom guide describes it.

  • Feel: you lie on the mattress rather than in it, and you feel more of the support underneath.
  • Who it suits: "Stomach sleepers and back sleepers who like a firmer surface usually start here," as the Aireloom guide says of its Tight Top. The firmness guide explains why: stomach sleepers "need the hips held up."
  • How it wears: with fewer soft inches above the support, there is less material to compress, so a tight top tends to keep a flatter surface over the years.
Stearns & Foster tight top mattress seen from the front, a flat quilted surface with straight sides and no separate top layer

Pillow top: a cushion stitched on

A pillow top is a separate layer of soft foam or fiber sewn onto the mattress, usually with a visible band or small gap where it meets the body of the bed. The firmness guide lists plush as "soft on top with support underneath. The classic pillow top," and a deep pillow top as ultra plush.

  • Feel: soft and cushioned on first contact, with the coils pushing back further down. The guide's own answer to "Does a pillow top make a mattress softer?" is "On top, yes. It adds cushioning without changing the support core."
  • Who it suits: side sleepers, whose shoulder and hip need room to sink in, and anyone who likes a traditional innerspring. Our type guide calls the classic innerspring "a coil unit with a thin comfort layer and a quilted top, often a pillow top."
  • How it wears: the soft layer is where you sink most, so it is where body impressions show first.

Euro top: the cushion squared off

A Euro top also adds a cushioning layer over the support, but it is sewn flush with the sides of the mattress, so the bed reads as one tall, squared block rather than a mattress with a cushion on top. Briganti's product pages describe it simply: "The Euro Top construction adds an extra layer of cushioning."

  • Feel: plush like a pillow top, but with straight sides and no seam on the sleep surface.
  • Who it suits: "side sleepers and anyone who wants a soft, cushioned first feel with coil support underneath," in the Aireloom guide's words.
  • How it wears: like a pillow top, the soft layers are where impressions form. Brands use the two names loosely, so lie on it; the label matters less than the feel.
Aireloom Euro top mattress in white, three-quarter view, with a squared cushioned top flush with the sides

Body impressions, height and care

Every mattress settles where you sleep. The more soft cushioning sits above the support, the more there is to settle, so pillow tops and Euro tops show impressions sooner than a tight top. How far depends on the materials. As our firmness guide puts it, "Firmness does not decide lifespan. Materials do. Dense foam and good coils outlast soft, low-density layers at any firmness," and our type guide adds that sagging "usually comes from low-density comfort foam, not the coils."

  • Rotate, do not flip. If only one side has the quilted top, it is one-sided. The FAQ says rotating head to foot "every few months, especially in the first couple of years, helps it wear evenly." Our mattress care guide gives the schedule.
  • Know what the warranty covers. Most brands cover "sagging or a body impression deeper than the brand's stated limit, measured with no weight on the bed," and not comfort preference. Our mattress warranty guide explains how a claim works.
  • Measure for sheets. A top adds height: Beautyrest Black's Series Three Firm is 15 inches, and 16.5 inches as a Firm Pillow Top. Our sheets guide says it plainly: "Tall mattress, pillow top or topper: look for deep pocket."

The models we carry, by top

  • Aireloom Preferred. The Tight Top Luxury Firm (also in Extra Firm) and the Euro Top Plush share the same 8-inch wrapped coil support, so trying one after the other shows what the top changes. Streamline and Luxetop differ in their comfort layers; the Aireloom guide covers all four lines, and the Aireloom collection has every model.
  • Stearns & Foster. The Lux Estate Firm Tight Top II and Lux Estate Medium Pillow Top II both pair coil-in-coil IntelliCoil innersprings with TEMPUR-Indulge memory foam. The feel labels differ, so you compare top and firmness together. Tight Top II also comes in the Estate and Legacy, Pillow Top II in the Estate and Reserve.
  • Beautyrest Black. Pillow tops across Series One to Four, in plush, medium and firm. The Beautyrest Black Series Three Firm Pillow Top is the one to try if you want a firm bed with a softer first touch.
  • Serta Perfect Sleeper X. On the Lexton Hybrid Medium Pillow Top, Serta says "a quilted top offers a classic feel and added layer of plush foam." The Max Hybrid comes in plush and firm pillow tops.
  • Briganti. Each Briganti page lists its construction: Tight Top Hybrid on the Aria Firm, Gianna Extra Firm and Emilia Medium Firm; Euro Top Hybrid on the Sofia Medium, Victoria Medium and Bella Plush.
Beautyrest Black firm pillow top mattress in black, front view, with the pillow top band above the side panel

Our pillow top collection holds the pillow tops and Euro tops together, from Beautyrest, Stearns & Foster, Serta, Aireloom, Briganti and more.

Which top to try first

  • You sleep on your stomach, or want to lie on the bed rather than in it: a tight top.
  • You sleep on your side, or want a soft, cushioned first feel: a pillow top or Euro top in plush or medium.
  • You want a firm bed but a softer surface: a firm pillow top.

Then do what our FAQ suggests: "lie on a few beds the way you actually sleep for five minutes each, and we will narrow it down with you."

Mattress Central, 3319 Glendale Blvd, Atwater Village, Los Angeles, open daily 9 AM to 8 PM, (323) 522-3410. Delivery is free, and around Los Angeles our own team sets it up (California orders). Every mattress comes with a 120-night comfort exchange, one time, if the feel is not right. Details are in our refund policy and FAQ. Browse the pillow top collection, or see all mattresses.

Previous article Beautyrest Black Series One to Five, explained
Next article Oprah's favorite mattress is a latex hybrid: 6 similar mattresses we carry in Los Angeles