Skip to content
Call (323) 522-3410 · Free delivery available nationwide, and a 120-night comfort exchange on mattresses
Call (323) 522-3410 · Free delivery
Corner cutaway of the Malouf gel memory foam mattress topper, showing the gel foam under its quilted cover

Mattress toppers: when one helps and when it does not

A mattress topper changes the feel of the top two or three inches of your bed, and nothing below. It cannot fix a mattress that has started to sag or has worn out. Here is how to tell which problem you have, what thickness, density and "cooling" mean, how a topper fits under your protector and sheets, and what we carry.

When a topper helps

If the mattress is new and feels too firm, do not buy a topper yet. Our FAQ says to give a new mattress three to four weeks, because it feels firmer at first. If the feel is still wrong after that, you can exchange it once within 120 nights under the comfort exchange, the right mattress instead of a patch on the wrong one. A topper makes sense when:

  • The mattress is sound but too firm. Flat, supportive, only a few years old, and you want a softer surface. This is the case a topper solves best.
  • It is a guest bed. A basic guest mattress gets a few nights a year. A topper makes it comfortable without buying a second bed.
  • A dorm, RV or trailer bed. Often thin and firm, and not always replaceable.
  • An all-foam bed that sleeps hot. If you like memory foam but wake up warm, a cooling topper changes the surface you lie on without replacing the mattress.
  • Softening a mattress you plan to keep. Past the exchange window, a topper softens a good mattress that turned out firmer than you like, while the mattress keeps doing the support work.
Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt topper on a mattress in a sunlit bedroom

When it does not

A topper sits on whatever is under it, so a problem below the surface comes through.

  • Sagging or a dip. A topper laid over a dip takes the shape of the dip within a few nights. You get a soft dip instead of a firm one.
  • A broken or protruding coil. Two inches of foam softens the poke. It does not remove it.
  • A mattress past eight to ten years. Our FAQ lists the signs: you wake up stiff, the edge has softened, you can feel a dip or a coil, you sleep better in a hotel, or the mattress is more than eight to ten years old. Any two of those and a topper is money spent on a bed that is going.
  • Pain that follows you to other beds. If you wake up sore at home, in a hotel and at a relative's house, the mattress is probably not the cause, and a topper is not the cure. That is a question for a professional.

A sagging mattress still inside its warranty may be a defect claim, not a topper purchase; the FAQ explains what a brand warranty covers. Our mattress care guide covers what sagging usually comes from, including a worn or unsupportive base.

Thickness and density, in plain words

Two numbers show up on memory foam toppers. Thickness is how much the feel changes: two inches softens the surface while the mattress still sets most of the feel; three inches changes it more, with a deeper sink, for a much-too-firm bed or a thin guest or RV mattress. Density is how the foam feels and responds, not how good it is. Lower density feels lighter and springs back faster; higher density molds more closely and responds more slowly. Neither is better.

Type Feel Changes the mattress Good for
Two-inch memory foam Soft, slow, close to the mattress A little Slightly too firm, lighter sleepers
Three-inch memory foam Deeper sink, more hug A lot Much too firm, thin guest or RV beds, heavier sleepers
Latex Springy, lifted, more open than memory foam Moderate Pressure relief without the hug, warm sleepers
Fiber-filled pad Light cushion, flattens faster Least A hint of softness, easy washing

Cooling toppers

"Cooling" on a topper usually means one of three things. A phase change cover is a fabric that absorbs some of your heat as you warm it and releases it as you cool. Gel-infused foam carries gel through the foam so the surface does not warm as quickly as plain memory foam. Ventilation means holes or channels cut through the foam so air can move through it instead of being held against you. The Malouf topper we carry combines the last two: gel-infused foam with a ventilated pin-core design. As our FAQ puts it, hybrids and innersprings move more air than all-foam beds, and cooling covers and gel foams help at the surface. For the full stack, from mattress to sheets, read our guide to sleeping hot in Los Angeles.

Fit: topper, protector, sheets

From the mattress up, the order is mattress, topper, protector, fitted sheet. The protector goes over the topper so it catches spills before they reach foam that cannot be washed. Before you buy a protector or sheets, measure the total height at the edge, from the bottom of the mattress to the top of the topper. That is the pocket depth you need: a three-inch topper on a 12-inch mattress is 15 inches. Our mattress protector guide and sheets guide cover pocket depth, split sizes and how to measure. For a split king on an adjustable base you need two twin XL toppers, one per side.

What we carry

We carry a small, chosen range in our toppers collection, each in every size from twin to California king, including twin XL for each half of a split king.

Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Cloud topper on a mattress in a bedroom with a blue wall

Toppers, like all bedding and accessories, are final sale once opened under our refund policy.

Try the mattress first

Lie on the floor model with the topper, then without it, five minutes each, the way you actually sleep. Often the honest answer is that you do not want a softer version of your mattress, you want a different mattress, and that is what the 120-night comfort exchange is for. A topper is the right buy when the mattress underneath is sound and only the surface is wrong.

Mattress Central, 3319 Glendale Blvd, Atwater Village, Los Angeles, open daily 9 AM to 8 PM, (323) 522-3410. Delivery is free, and around Los Angeles our own team sets it up (California orders). Every mattress comes with a 120-night comfort exchange; toppers are final sale once opened. Details are in our FAQ. Browse toppers, protectors and bedding, or see all mattresses.

Next article 25 questions customers ask us about mattresses